AI code modernization tools compared: AWS Transform, GitHub Copilot, IBM watsonx and more

- AI tools now automate much of the repetitive modernization work, from code analysis and documentation to version upgrades, cutting some tasks from months to weeks.
- The tools aren’t interchangeable: AWS Transform fits large programs moving to AWS, GitHub Copilot app modernization suits Java and .NET upgrades inside the IDE, and IBM Bob is built for COBOL that stays on the mainframe.
- For unusual stacks like VB6 or Delphi, general-purpose AI coding agents combined with test generators offer the most flexibility.
- Tool licenses are rarely the main cost; code complexity, test coverage and validation needs drive the budget.
- AI doesn’t replace engineers: every AI-generated change still needs testing, human review and approval.
- A phased approach (assess, pilot, then scale) reduces risk and gives you real data instead of vendor benchmarks.
Gartner predicts that AI-augmented tools will handle 90% of software modernization work by 2029, a sharp rise from under 15% in 2025. The forecast reflects how quickly the tooling has matured: major cloud and enterprise software vendors now offer AI agents that analyze COBOL, port Windows-bound .NET Framework applications to cross-platform .NET, upgrade Java versions and more, promising to finish in weeks work that used to take months.
These tools, however, are not interchangeable. Each covers different languages, platforms and stages of the modernization process, and their pricing models vary widely. This guide compares the leading AI code modernization tools (what each does well and where each falls short) so you can choose the one that fits your codebase rather than the one with the loudest launch.
What are AI code modernization tools?
AI code modernization tools are software platforms that use large language models (LLMs), AI agents, and, in some cases, static code analysis to accelerate legacy software modernization. Depending on the tool, they can map dependencies, explain and document existing code, plan migrations, refactor or translate code, and generate tests to help verify that the modernized application preserves the original behavior. Engineers remain responsible for reviewing changes and approving production releases.
What exactly do they automate?
AI tools can automate different stages of a modernization project. Some cover much of the process, from initial assessment to code transformation and validation. Others focus on specific tasks.
- Discovery and assessment: analyzing code structure, mapping dependencies and identifying outdated components, compatibility issues and potential migration risks.
- Documentation: explaining existing code and helping uncover business rules that may not be documented or fully understood by the current team.
- Planning: identifying components that need modernization, suggesting migration steps and, in some cases, recommending changes to the architecture.
- Transformation: translating code into another language (COBOL to Java), migrating to a modern framework or runtime (.NET Framework to cross-platform .NET), or upgrading versions (Java 8 to Java 21).
- Build repair: resolving compilation errors, replacing deprecated APIs and fixing dependency issues that arise during migration.
- Testing and validation: generating tests, running existing test suites and identifying issues that could affect the modernized application’s behavior.
Assistants, agents and platforms
AI modernization tools also differ in how independently they work and how much code they can handle. They generally fall into three categories:
- Assistants help developers understand, refactor and update code inside an IDE. They suggest changes that developers review and apply, typically working on focused tasks rather than managing an entire migration.
- Agents carry out multi-step tasks with less manual intervention. For example, an agent can analyze a project, plan an upgrade, modify code, fix build errors and run tests. Developers provide instructions, review results and intervene when needed.
- Platforms support modernization across multiple applications and teams. They combine automation with capabilities such as centralized project management, collaboration, progress tracking and review workflows. AWS Transform is one example, supporting parallel modernization of hundreds of applications.
The lines between these categories are blurring, as many vendors now offer more than one level. The distinction still matters when choosing a tool: an assistant suits a developer upgrading a single service, while a platform is built for a program that spans a whole application portfolio.
AI tools vs. traditional rule-based converters
Automated code conversion isn’t new. Rule-based converters have been translating legacy code for decades. What AI changes is how code is analyzed and transformed, which affects the flexibility, predictability and risks of modernization.
Rule-based converters follow predefined transformation rules. The same input and configuration produce consistent results, making changes easier to reproduce and trace. However, many traditional converters preserve much of the old code structure. The result can be Java that compiles but still looks and behaves like COBOL, making it difficult for modern developers to understand and maintain.
LLM-based tools interpret code in context, so they can restructure logic into idiomatic code that follows the conventions of the target language. However, this flexibility comes with risks. AI code generation may change business logic, miss edge cases or introduce subtle errors. The output can also vary between runs.
That’s why some modernization tools combine both approaches. For example, GitHub Copilot modernization for Java uses OpenRewrite for rule-based transformations and AI agents to resolve build errors, handle more complex changes and validate the upgraded application.
Benefits of AI in legacy modernization
Legacy modernization has traditionally been slow, expensive and heavily dependent on manual work. AI tools are changing that, and the benefits are already visible in real projects.
1. Shorter timelines
AI speeds up the repetitive parts of modernization, such as discovery, documentation and routine upgrades. Amazon, for example, reports that using Amazon Q Developer reduced the average time to upgrade an application to Java 17 from around 50 developer-days to just a few hours. Across tens of thousands of applications, the company estimates it saved the equivalent of 4,500 developer-years of work.
However, results vary widely depending on the complexity of the project. Gartner predicts that more than 70% of mainframe exit projects started in 2026 will fail to deliver their intended benefits because organizations overestimate what generative AI can achieve.
2. Lower technical debt
Technical debt consumes a budget that could otherwise fund new development. According to Deloitte’s modeling, companies that prioritize modernization could recover more than half of the technology value trapped by technical debt over five years. Infrastructure modernization alone could reduce technical debt by 18% over the same period, compared with a company that keeps its current approach.
AI tools support these efforts by reducing the manual work involved in code analysis, refactoring and upgrades. This makes it easier for teams to tackle technical debt that would otherwise stay in the backlog.
3. Less dependence on scarce experts
Many legacy systems depend on a handful of developers who understand both the technology and the business logic behind the code. Finding replacements can be difficult, especially for older programming languages. VB6 is a clear example.
AI tools reduce this dependence. They help teams understand what legacy code does, extract the business rules buried in it and draft up-to-date documentation. Experienced developers and business experts still need to verify the results, but AI can reduce the amount of manual analysis required. The resulting documentation also makes it easier to transfer knowledge to other developers instead of relying on just a few specialists.
4. Large-scale, repetitive change becomes feasible
Some modernization tasks aren’t difficult, just enormous: the same change has to be made across thousands of files, so the work is too expensive to do by hand and stays in the backlog for years.
AI makes this kind of change more manageable. In one internal migration at Google, which affected tens of thousands of code locations, 80% of the code modifications in the final changes were AI-generated. Engineers also estimated a 50% reduction in total migration time, including review and rollout. Google reports that AI-assisted workflows helped complete migrations that had been stalled for several years.
5. Faster framework upgrades
Frameworks such as .NET and Java release new versions regularly, and older versions eventually stop receiving security updates. This forces companies to upgrade their applications every few years, which is slow, repetitive work when done by hand.
AI agents speed it up considerably. Microsoft says its Xbox team used GitHub Copilot to upgrade a core service from .NET 6 to .NET 8 and cut manual migration effort by 88%. Experian reports that AWS Transform reduced each of its .NET 6 to .NET 8 upgrade projects from 15 sprints to 8.
AI code modernization tools compared
AI code modernization tools take different approaches and work with different tech stacks, so they aren’t interchangeable. Below is the overview of what each one does well, what it costs and where it falls short.
AWS Transform
AWS Transform is AWS’s agentic AI service for large-scale migration and modernization. It supports mainframe applications, Windows and .NET workloads, SQL Server databases and VMware environments. Its custom transformation capabilities also cover tasks such as Java upgrades, framework migrations and organization-specific code changes.
Generally available since May 2025, AWS Transform provides a shared web interface where teams can analyze applications, generate modernization plans, track progress and review results. Depending on the transformation, developers can also work through an IDE or command-line interface.
- Strengths: wide workload coverage in one service; mainframe analysis that includes business logic extraction, data lineage and data dictionary generation for COBOL, PL/I and JCL code; coordinated migration of SQL Server databases to Aurora PostgreSQL together with the .NET applications that depend on them; human-in-the-loop approvals.
- Pricing: standard migration and modernization capabilities are free, while continuous modernization and custom transformations cost extra. AWS infrastructure, storage and implementation services are billed separately.
- Real trade-off: AWS Transform is built to land you on AWS. Companies pursuing a cloud-neutral strategy should check which target platforms each transformation supports and whether the code, assessment data and other outputs can be reused with other tools if their plans change.
GitHub Copilot app modernization
GitHub Copilot app modernization is a set of AI agents that help developers assess, upgrade and modernize applications. It supports Java and .NET upgrades, C++ toolset modernization, JavaScript/TypeScript dependency updates and selected Python migrations. It also helps migrate supported applications to Azure.
Introduced in May 2025 for .NET upgrades, the tool has expanded to support more languages and modernization scenarios. It is available in Visual Studio Code, IntelliJ IDEA and Visual Studio, depending on the language, as well as through GitHub Copilot CLI.
- Strengths: works inside the tools developers already use; support for multiple languages and frameworks; combines rule-based transformations, including OpenRewrite for Java, with AI-assisted code fixes; structured upgrade plans and build validation.
- Pricing: included in GitHub Copilot plans, such as Business and Enterprise; modernization tasks draw on each plan’s monthly pool of AI credits, and usage beyond the pool is billed at $0.01 per credit.
- Real trade-off: best suited to supported application languages and frameworks rather than mainframe modernization; migration guidance is tuned for Azure; large modernization jobs can push usage past the included credits, so costs are less predictable than a flat license.
IBM Bob Premium Package for Z (formerly watsonx Code Assistant for Z)
IBM’s earlier mainframe modernization tool, watsonx Code Assistant for Z (WCA4Z), helped developers understand, document, refactor and transform legacy COBOL applications. In 2026, IBM introduced Bob, a broader AI development assistant, and launched the Bob Premium Package for Z in June. The package supersedes WCA4Z and adds mainframe-specific analysis, development and modernization capabilities to IBM Bob.
The package has two modes: Z Architect analyzes applications, maps dependencies and plans changes, while Z Code explains, generates and refactors code. It supports COBOL, PL/I, JCL, REXX and Assembler, including COBOL and PL/I transformation to Java.
- Strengths: deep IBM Z expertise, including CICS, IMS, Db2 and MQ awareness; enterprise-wide dependency and impact analysis; business rule extraction and data dictionary generation; separate modes for architectural analysis and code changes, with human approval checkpoints.
- Pricing: IBM Bob individual plans start at $20 per month, but the Premium Package for Z is an enterprise add-on with custom pricing available through IBM sales.
- Real trade-off: focused on IBM Z rather than general-purpose modernization, and existing WCA4Z customers must plan their transition to Bob.
General-purpose AI agents and specialist helpers
Not every modernization project needs a dedicated platform. General-purpose AI coding agents and specialist tools can cover parts of the work on their own or fill gaps left by the platforms above.
- Claude Code, Gemini Code Assist, Devin: flexible AI coding tools that work with any language and cloud. They handle code exploration, documentation and refactoring well. Trade-off: they don’t come with a dedicated end-to-end modernization workflow, so your team supplies the governance, prompts and validation process.
- Diffblue Cover: its Cover product writes regression unit tests for Java that capture how the code currently behaves. In 2026, the company added a Testing Agent that generates tests for Java and Python on top of AI coding agents such as Claude Code and GitHub Copilot. Trade-off: it covers testing only, and supports a limited set of languages.
| Tool | Best for | Technologies covered | Moves you toward | Main limitation |
| AWS Transform | Large modernization programs across many applications | Mainframe (COBOL, PL/I, JCL), .NET Framework, SQL Server, VMware, plus custom transformations | AWS | Lock-in risk: outputs may be hard to reuse outside AWS |
| GitHub Copilot app modernization | Developer-led upgrades of individual applications | Java, .NET, C++ toolset upgrades, JavaScript/TypeScript packages, selected Python migrations | Azure for cloud migration; upgrades work anywhere | No mainframe or COBOL support |
| IBM Bob Premium Package for Z | Modernizing COBOL applications that stay on the mainframe | COBOL, PL/I, JCL, REXX, Assembler | IBM Z | Not designed for moving off the mainframe |
| Claude Code, Gemini Code Assist, Devin | Exploration, documentation, refactoring and custom migrations | Any language | No preference | No built-in modernization workflow |
| Diffblue | Building a regression test safety net before code changes | Java and Kotlin (Cover); Java and Python (Testing Agent) | No preference | Covers testing only |
When to choose which AI code modernization tool
No single tool is the best choice for every project. The right one depends on two things: what your legacy system is built on and where you want it to end up. The scenarios below match the most common starting points to the tools that fit them best.
You run COBOL or PL/I on a mainframe and want to leave it
If AWS is your target cloud, start with AWS Transform for mainframe. It analyzes legacy code, extracts business rules, maps data lineage and refactors COBOL applications to Java. AWS says it can accelerate mainframe modernization timelines by up to 50%. Involve your mainframe experts early, so they can validate the extracted business rules while they’re still on staff.
Your COBOL is staying on IBM Z, but it must become maintainable
If your COBOL applications will stay on the mainframe, the right tool is IBM Bob with the Premium Package for Z, the successor to IBM watsonx Code Assistant for Z. Rather than moving applications off the mainframe, it helps teams understand, document and refactor COBOL where it already runs.
Because IBM Bob understands the IBM Z environment, including middleware and dependencies across the whole application estate, it’s the specialist option for teams committed to the platform.
You have .NET Framework apps tied to Windows Server licenses
If you’re moving to AWS, AWS Transform for .NET ports .NET Framework applications to cross-platform .NET that can run on Linux. AWS says it works up to four times faster than traditional methods and can cut operating costs by up to 40% by removing the need for Windows Server licenses.
For any other target, whether Azure, another cloud or your own servers, GitHub Copilot app modernization handles the same upgrade from inside Visual Studio or VS Code, one application at a time. Its Azure-specific features only matter if you’re migrating to Azure; the upgraded code runs anywhere.
Your Java services have drifted across versions
GitHub Copilot app modernization is a practical default for this scenario. It analyzes each project, drafts an upgrade plan, applies OpenRewrite recipes for routine changes, fixes build errors, runs tests and scans the upgraded code for known vulnerabilities.
When many services need upgrading, its Modernize CLI lets architects assess and plan upgrades across several applications at once, then hand the work to developers. Java upgrades and Java-to-Azure migration scenarios are generally available.
Your stack is unusual, multi-cloud, or you need to avoid lock-in
VB6, Delphi, ColdFusion, PowerBuilder and in-house frameworks rarely have ready-made modernization workflows in the major vendors’ tools. Here, general-purpose agents such as Claude Code or Gemini Code Assist can analyze and rewrite the code, and a test generator such as Diffblue can build a safety net for the new codebase if it’s written in Java or Python. In the hands of experienced engineers, this combination gives you flexibility without tying your roadmap to one cloud.
Who’s involved and how it works operationally
AI tools change how the effort is split, not who is accountable for the result. Every AI-generated change still needs people to define the approach, check the output and make sure the new system behaves like the old one. A typical modernization team includes:
- Modernization architect: chooses the target architecture and tools, configures the AI agents and custom transformation rules and defines the validation strategy.
- Developers: prepare the context the agents work from, such as coding standards and project documentation, review AI-generated pull requests, fix edge cases and refactor toward idiomatic code.
- QA and test automation engineers: build regression suites and equivalence checks, for example by replaying real production inputs through both the old and new systems and comparing the results.
- Security engineers: review AI-generated code for vulnerabilities, check upgraded dependencies for known security issues and make sure the use of AI tools follows the client’s data protection policies.
- DevOps / cloud engineers: handle infrastructure as code, CI/CD (continuous integration and delivery) and cutover.
The team also relies on input from the client’s side. Legacy subject-matter experts, the people who know the system best, confirm the extracted business rules and explain undocumented behavior that no tool can infer from the code.
How to modernize with AI code migration tools: a 3-phase playbook
Choosing the right tool is only part of the job. How you introduce it matters just as much. The playbook below breaks the work into three phases — each phase reduces risks before the next one begins.
Phase 1: Assess and prove
The goal of this phase is to understand what you have and build the foundation for a reliable pilot.
- Inventory the applications, languages, dependencies and data stores in scope.
- Run AI-assisted discovery to generate documentation and dependency maps.
- Have legacy subject-matter experts review the extracted business rules and flag anything missing or wrong.
- Measure test coverage, and add baseline regression tests where it’s thin, using AI test generators for supported languages or recorded production inputs for older systems.
Phase 2: Pilot and calibrate
This phase tests the tools on real code and uses the results to adjust your approach before scaling up.
- Pick one bounded, valuable module as a pilot, agree on success metrics such as effort saved, defect rate and performance, and run it through your chosen tools.
- Compare old and new behavior using the baseline regression tests and replayed production inputs.
- Measure the results against the success metrics agreed at the start of the pilot.
- Record what the AI got wrong and turn the fixes into custom transformation rules or agent instructions.
- Refine the reference architecture, coding standards and review checklists.
- Re-estimate the full program using real pilot data, not vendor benchmarks.
Phase 3: Scale and operate (ongoing)
Once the pilot proves the approach, the work shifts to rolling it out across the system safely and keeping the codebase current afterwards.
- Move module by module, gradually replacing parts of the legacy system rather than switching everything over at once.
- Automate builds, tests and security scans in CI/CD for every AI-generated change.
- Run old and new systems in parallel for critical flows before switching over.
- Decommission legacy components and track license and infrastructure savings.
- Use AI agents to handle recurring framework and dependency upgrades, with the same review process as the main project, so the debt doesn’t build up again.
For a deeper look at validation techniques, see our notes on using LLMs for code migration.
What does AI legacy modernization cost?
Tool licenses are often the smallest line item. Pricing models vary: GitHub Copilot app modernization is included in Copilot plans and draws on each plan’s monthly AI credits, AWS Transform offers its core migration and modernization features free and charges for custom and continuous modernization, and IBM sells Bob as subscriptions, with the Premium Package for Z available through IBM’s sales team.
The real cost drivers are:
- Code volume and complexity: lines of code matter less than tangled dependencies, dynamic SQL and assembler routines.
- Test coverage: low coverage means paying to build a safety net before anything moves.
- Validation depth: regulated industries need equivalence evidence and audit trails.
- Target architecture: a like-for-like port costs far less than a move to microservices.
- Team location and model: blended rates differ widely between onshore, nearshore and offshore teams. Eastern European developer hubs often combine strong engineering skills with mid-range rates.
Making AI modernization succeed long term
The right tools speed up modernization, but lasting results depend on the practices around them: how you validate AI output, how you govern changes and how you keep the system from falling behind again.
Treat tests as the product
Whatever tool you pick, its output is only as trustworthy as your regression suite. Before you scale, invest in characterization tests, which record how the legacy system behaves today, along with replayed production inputs and equivalence checks that confirm the new system produces the same results.
Gartner’s research on AI-augmented code modernization tools makes the same point: without broad, AI-assisted test coverage, legacy systems can’t be safely refactored or migrated.
Govern AI like any other contributor
AI-generated pull requests should get the same scrutiny as human ones: code review, static analysis, security scanning and traceability from each change back to the legacy code it replaces. Keep humans at key checkpoints and log what the agents did and why.
This is your main defense against one of the biggest risks in AI modernization: code that compiles and passes a quick review but quietly changes how the business logic works.
Make modernization continuous
The biggest long-term gain isn’t a single migration. It’s never falling this far behind again. AI tools now make it practical to keep codebases current on an ongoing basis: they can regularly scan repositories for outdated frameworks, end-of-life dependencies and security vulnerabilities, then propose upgrades for engineers to review. Schedule framework and runtime upgrades as routine maintenance, not as a crisis every 10 years.
Conclusion
AI code modernization tools have made projects that were once unaffordable realistic. Work that used to take months, such as analyzing legacy code, documenting business rules and upgrading frameworks, can now be done in weeks, and systems that seemed too risky to touch are finally within reach. But the winners won’t be the teams with the most advanced agents. They will be the teams that choose the right tool for their stack and pair it with disciplined testing, expert review and phased delivery, so that speed doesn’t come at the cost of reliability.
If you want a partner to help choose the tools, build the safety net and carry the program through cutover, contact Abto Software to discuss your legacy system.
FAQ
No. AI can automate a large share of the repetitive work. In one of Google’s internal migrations, for example, 80% of the code changes were AI-generated. But architecture decisions, ambiguous business rules and final validation still need engineers and domain experts.
Not entirely, but it delivers the most value there. Its discovery and documentation outputs have value on their own, and code-level changes such as Java version upgrades or ports to cross-platform .NET produce code that can run anywhere. However, its mainframe, VMware and database migration paths, deployment patterns and cost savings are designed around AWS. If you’re multi-cloud, check how portable its outputs are before you commit.
GitHub Copilot is a general-purpose AI coding assistant: it suggests code as you type, answers questions in chat and can carry out multi-step coding tasks in agent mode. App modernization is a dedicated workflow built on top of Copilot agent mode for upgrading and migrating applications: it assesses a whole project, generates an upgrade plan, applies deterministic refactoring recipes where available, fixes the build, validates the result with tests and scans upgraded dependencies for known vulnerabilities.
Yes. In 2026, IBM made the Bob Premium Package for Z generally available and officially positioned it as the successor to WCA4Z, bringing its mainframe AI capabilities into IBM Bob. If you already use WCA4Z, check with IBM about support timelines and migration options before you plan your move.
AI tools speed up modernization, but they also introduce risks that traditional projects didn’t face, or make existing ones harder to spot. Most of them come from the volume and speed of AI-generated changes rather than from the tools themselves. The main risks are:
- Business logic that changes without anyone noticing
- Code that carries the old system’s structure and technical debt into the new one
- Too few reviewers for the volume of AI output
- Vendor lock-in
- Sending sensitive code to external AI models
A reliable modernization partner can help you reduce these risks by building strong test coverage before any code changes, reviewing every AI-generated change, choosing tools that fit your long-term plans and setting clear rules for how your code is handled.
It’s rarely an either-or choice, since modernization partners use these same tools. The real question is whether your team can run the project on its own. If your stack fits a tool’s main path and you have strong in-house testing and review capacity, a tool may be enough. If you have mixed or unusual technologies, little documentation, strict compliance requirements or a team already stretched by day-to-day work, an experienced partner adds the governance, validation and capacity that tools don’t provide.



